Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Oneness Theory - Do No Harm




I have a major problem with the ideal expressed in the statement “Do no harm.”

As with all ideals they are impossible to achieve unless the terms of reference are idealistic, at least in theory. If the ideal of do no harm is to be successful it has to be approached from two perspectives; first using current dominant world view (Duality) thinking, second using a Paradigm of OT (OT) thinking.

The current dominant world is dualistic at root. What do I mean? I mean that we humans have constructed a world based on the idea of duality. The essence of this world view is separateness. To implement this idea it needs two opposing components to work in balance to achieve harmony. In the case of an ideal a judgment call is needed to decide which component of duality is considered ideal.  If the components do not work in balance we have disharmony. Too much harmony equals chaos. If the ideal judgment call is say, that Heaven is the place where all good is accumulated then bad must be reduced to zero. Conflict is the engine of duality.

From the time of civilization this model of human thinking and thus behavior has been dominant. It is based on any number of ideas that are opposites. In the beginning the ideas were mainly sensory based such as; night and day, hot and cold, sweet and sour, black and white, soft and loud, smooth and coarse etc. Later human thinking developed increasingly abstract concepts such as:
·         Good and bad (Morals/Ethics).
·         Yin and yang (Balance).
·         Matter and anti matter (Quantum physics).
·         Cause and effect (Physics), etc. 

Around the time of the creation of the sensory concepts the idea of ideals was conceptualized. Thus the conception of:
·         Perfection.
·         Excellence.
·         Utopia.
·         Sub-ring of a ring (Mathematics).
·         The philosophical nature of ideal, etc.

These ideals are often thought of as goals for human aspirations in a physical world that if achieved would allow access to a metaphysical world. In fact the idea was often expressed that the division between the metaphysical and physical worlds was the achievement of perfection (Enlightenment).

As all these concepts developed and were given values a more complex world view paradigm of division was created. To make these concepts work in our ever increasing un-natural divisive world of separation, compromises were made by inventing constants and limits through the creation of laws and definitions.
Questions still arose such as:
·         How good or how bad?
·         What is evil?
·         Shades of grey?
·         Balance or ideal?
·         Other worlds?
·         Chicken or the egg?
·         Do no harm?

To explain the validity for many new concepts the idea of the rational human mind was invented. Cognitive reasoning assumed equal weight in human thinking with intuition, myth, fiction, tradition and religion. The idea of Logic was born and developed two main branches:
1.       Mathematical (De Morgan's Laws)  
2.       Philosophical (Inference, rational thought, truth).

The concepts of fact, truth and theory were developed. Where science could provide a reasonable answer the scientific method, simple logic or a combination of both was more readily accepted as the proof of truth. Where truth or fact could not be proven a weight of evidence was used to give a degree of probability of fact or truth. Where science could not provide any reasonable or logic as proof of fact or truth, people turned to the realm of the metaphysical. Answers based on tradition or faith were accepted as proof of truth by an act of faith. Thus the idea of separateness (Duality) expanded and became the underlying rationale for human affairs.

Dualistic thinking about ideals such as do no harm is doomed to failure because the truth or falsity of the ideal is unable to be resolved to satisfy all arguments. The question is do no harm, good or bad, cannot be definitively answered using Dualistic (Division) thinking. The words do no harm immediately invite a counter argument Do harm. The ensuing debate will not resolve this question without placing judgment on the statement, do no harm. These judgments may be subjective on the one hand and objective (Weight of evidence) on the other hand. The philosophical truth of the statement will remain indeterminate at best and determinate at worst.

If one approaches the statement do no harm from the perspective of a world view of Oneness Theory thinking the answer can be resolved completely and easily. In OT thinking there is no concept of separateness. The subject object split is resolved and the observer truly becomes the observed. In OT thinking there is no proof, no truth no law. There is simply a requirement to meet the conditions of Oneness. In this paradigm a statement such as do no harm exists in itself, philosophically.

To determine its suitability to exist in an OT thinking world it must be capable of existing without proof but merely meets the needs of the OT paradigm. Thus air exists as does water, fire, gravity, etc for they fit a holistic, holographic physical universe (Holon). Similarly thought exists in and of itself and needs no other qualification. The idea of do no harm can be thought therefore it exists as an idea but for it to become a concept it must be acted upon (Implemented).

In OT thinking there are no separate things. Everything physical that exists does so as part of the whole and is in turn the whole itself (Holon). Ideas as thoughts are the non-particle evidence of the metaphysical world and exist in both metaphysical and physical worlds. For ideas to be accepted as capable of conceptualization (Implementation) in a world of OT thinking they must answer both of the following questions:
1.       Will the concept fit the paradigm of a holistic, holographic world of OT?
2.       Will the concept improve the paradigm of a holistic, holographic world of OT?

In this case the statement do no harm I take to relate to the idea of doing good. The word good does not exist in OT thinking. On that basis alone the concept of, do no harm, cannot exist. However for the purposes of understanding OT thinking paradigm let’s suppose the question needs to answered anyway.

Question 1:   Will the concept, do no harm, fit the paradigm of a; holistic, holographic world of OT
Answer:             No.
Question 2:   Will do no harm improve the paradigm of a holistic, holographic world of OT?
Answer:              No

If either answer is in the negative the other question need not be posed. Thus is in this case the statement do no harm will not fit the paradigm of Oneness, for there is no concept of good & bad (Evil).

Disclaimer:

  1. Mileage may vary.
  2. I am responsible for what I write. I am not responsible for how it is perceived.
 © Copyright Geoff Ogilvie 2006-2018